Hotels in ST CROIX, VI
Club Comanche Inn
About this property
Nestled on the quaint streets of Christiansted, the Club Comanche Inn provides the most exceptional personal service in an authentic Caribbean setting. The antique West Indian appeal of the inn is in part related to its rich past as a cornerstone in the history of downtown Christiansted. A significant landscape feature along the popular Christiansted Harbor Boardwalk, the inn offers over ten unique rooms to choose from. The property includes two buildings joined together by a wooden skywalk bridge that spans the one lane street and walkway below, to the vintage built Bridge House building and one of the most identifiable landmarks of the skyline of Christiansted, the famous Comanche Mill Club. The club features a mill replica built along the Christiansted Harbor Boardwalk that once served as an island wedding chapel. The garden grounds feature a palm grotto and paved footpaths carefully landscaped with tropical plants and flowers, and outdoor seating. Both buildings are conveniently located near the newly opened downtown casino, and within a short walk to art galleries, duty-free shops, custom jewelers, fine restaurants and waterfront bars, excursion boat operators, dive shops and the seaplane terminal. The Club Comanche Inn features modern amenities and services, while still retaining the casual elegance of the Caribbean and the historic charms desired of a West Indian island getaway.
Popular facilities
See all facilitiesGood to know
- Check-in
- From 15:00
- Check-out
- Until 11:00
- Luggage storage
- Available
- Room types
- 4
Room Information
Rooms
1 / 3 CLASSIC ROOM
- 1 x Double bed 131-150 width
- Shower
- Hairdryer
- Direct dial telephone
- TV
- Bathroom
- Safe
- Individually adjustable air conditioning
- Tea and coffee making facilities
What's the price for your stay?
Add your dates to see current rates.
1 / 2 SUITE PREMIUM
- 1 x Queen-size bed 150-154 width
- Bathroom
- Safe
- Individually adjustable air conditioning
- Tea and coffee making facilities
- TV
- Direct dial telephone
- Shower
- Hairdryer
What's the price for your stay?
Add your dates to see current rates.
1 / 3 DOUBLE CLASSIC DOUBLE BED
What's the price for your stay?
Add your dates to see current rates.
1 / 2 SUITE PREMIUM
What's the price for your stay?
Add your dates to see current rates.
Guest reviews
Recent reviews shared by hotel guests
Guest Rating
6/10
Pleasant Featured review
Patrick B.
10/10
The hotel manager, Angie, was welcoming, professional, and really on the ball. Julia also took care of us from the moment we arrived, in a friendly and professional way. Everyone we met who worked with or was associated with the hotel was cheerful and friendly. Our room was comfortable and super clean. The Comanche is quaint, with wooden stairs, an old-world feel, and a library full of lovely old, interesting books. It’s steps from great restaurants, shops, and historic spots. I’d recommend it, and we’ll definitely return to Comanche next time we’re in gorgeous St. Croix. Keep up the great work, Comanche team.
Ethan C.
10/10
Upstairs, the bar has a shady spot with nice cross breezes and a good view over downtown. The GM, Jamie, is passionate about making the stay feel distinctive. Jamie spent time telling us about the site’s history and showing us its nooks and crannies. The Comanche club has wonderful historic character. It feels like hanging out in an Ernest Hemingway novel, in a 300-year-old building with good bones. I’d recommend it to anyone who enjoys history, good food, art, spirits, and a thoughtfully put-together experience.
Derek W.
10/10
That big covered outdoor bar, with its antique wood, is a great spot to relax, socialize, or work remotely, day or night. It’s also a nice place to meet locals and other travelers. This is an independent, laid-back island 3-star hotel with a friendly atmosphere and historic feel. The location is terrific, right in the heart of Christiansted for shopping, exploring, tours, and nightlife. The pool was closed while I was there.
Kara J.
10/10
Jamey looked after us, and her customer service was so good that we added another day to our stay. The room was clean, and the view was amazing. The Comanche is a historic property, right in the middle of everything in Christiansted. It’s been around since 1756, which is quite something. We had a wonderful stay and will definitely be back in June. Thanks again for everything, Jamey!
Jared M.
2/10
The staff were amazing, and the hotel is right in the heart of Christiansted, with lots of places within walking distance. Music drifts in from the boardwalk, so there’s a steady beat in the background. If you need a little sound to fall asleep, this might suit you. Our bed wasn’t very comfortable, and we were told that since we were staying longer, the nicer rooms are usually reserved for shorter visits. The pool was out of service while we were there. There was a convenient mini fridge in the room, but it might not be the best setup if you’re traveling with a partner. The bathroom had a vented door, no fan, and was right next to the bed. Let’s just say there’s no mystery left.
Amenities
Everything available at this property
30 Facilities
General Services
27 available- Year of most recent renovation
- Number of floors (main building)
- Number of floors (annexe)
- Single rooms
- Double rooms
- Junior suites
- Suites
- boutique hotel
- American Express
- MasterCard
- Visa
- Harbour
- Key Collection
- Check In Hour
- Check Out Hour
- Room service
- Air conditioning in public areas
- Hotel safe
- Garden
- Luggage room
- Deposit on arrival
- Identification card at arrival
- Flight information required
- No hen/stag or any other parties allowed
- Non Smoking Establishment
- Minimum Check In Age
- Cash Free
Internet
1 available- Wi Fi
Sports
1 available- Golf course
Room Amenities
1 available- Towels and bed linen
What's nearby
Explore attractions, restaurants and transport around the hotel
41 places nearby
Closest Ferry Gallows Bay Ferry Dock
618 m 8 min walk
Top attraction nearbyChristiansted Boardwalk
81 m 1 min walk
Dining nearby 20 Restaurants
24 m 1 min walk
Attractions
20- Christiansted Boardwalk81 m 1 min walk
- Christiansted National Historic Site227 m 3 min walk
- Fort Christiansvaern281 m 4 min walk
- Haunt: Historic Ghost Tours - St. Croix310 m 4 min walk
- Tan Tan Tours354 m 4 min walk
Restaurants
20- Shupe's on the Boardwalk24 m 1 min walk
- Chupacabra Tacos USVI24 m 1 min walk
- The Mill Boardwalk Bar Brick Oven Pizza30 m 1 min walk
- Estera34 m 1 min walk
- Toast Diner36 m 1 min walk
Transit
1- Gallows Bay Ferry DockFerry618 m 8 min walk
Stay rules
Important conditions for your stay
Check-in15:00 – 19:00Front desk timing
Check-out11:00Departure timing