Rogues' Harbor Inn

At the historic Rogue’s Harbor Inn, the staff were tremendous, breakfast was exactly what I needed, and my room was clean and well kept. I forgot something important to me, and they even offered to ship it back to my apartment in providence, which was the cherry on top. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a place in Lansing or near Ithaca.

The attached Corner Pub feels like a local hangout, with a friendly crowd and staff and above-average pub food. It's close to Ithaca, NY, and to wineries around the nearby five finger lakes. There's also a brewery nearby, though I didn't get to visit it. There isn't much to do within walking distance, and the roads and traffic make walking unpleasant. This is a rustic, historic inn that its current owner, Eileen, has refurbished nicely. She's on site and cooks and serves a good breakfast. The accommodations were nice enough, with a reasonably well-appointed room at a fair price.

The inn is conveniently near Ithaca but tucked just up the lake, and it's about half the price of the more crowded options in Ithaca proper, only a short, pretty drive away. For a Finger Lakes visit, I'd expect the Rogues Harbor Inn to add to the peaceful countryside experience with its refined, sophisticated charm. I'll recommend it to friends and come back soon. I was really impressed by the atmosphere and quality. The historic building and rooms are tastefully decorated, with modern, well-maintained furnishings. Eileen and the staff are kind and accommodating. They pay close attention to little things, both in the distinctive rooms and when serving food in the dining atrium, and that care makes a big difference. It's a great value for the price.

The pub attached to the inn was a welcome stop after our four-hour drive. We got in at 7 on Friday and could eat without heading back out. The room was roomy and very clean, and the first-floor lobby had plenty for guests, including paper plates, plastic utensils, ice, coffee, tea, hot cocoa, and a refrigerator. Staff were helpful and friendly, and the morning hostess and chef made us feel welcome. I live somewhere quiet with hardly any traffic, but the cars passing here didn't bother me. Ithaca is close and easy to get to. I'd stay here again on another visit.