Sunset Beach Hotel
About this property
Popular facilities
See all facilitiesGood to know
- Check-in
- From 15:00
- Check-out
- Until 11:00
- Pets
- Allowed
- Luggage storage
- Available
- Smoking
- Smoke-free
- Room types
- 3
Room Information
Rooms
Quadruple Suite with bay view
- 4 guests
- Private bathroom
- air-conditioning
- bathrobe
- blackout-blinds
- hairdryer
- hypoallergenic
- iron
- mini-bar
- mirror
- private-bathroom
- safe
- slippers
- soundproofing
Add your dates to see current rates.
Double Suite with bay view
- 2 guests
- full double bed
- Private bathroom
- air-conditioning
- bathrobe
- blackout-blinds
- hairdryer
- hypoallergenic
- iron
- mini-bar
- mirror
- private-bathroom
- safe
- slippers
- soundproofing
Add your dates to see current rates.
Suite
- Private bathroom
- air-conditioning
- bathrobe
- blackout-blinds
- hairdryer
- hypoallergenic
- iron
- mini-bar
- mirror
- private-bathroom
- safe
- slippers
- soundproofing
Add your dates to see current rates.
Guest reviews
Recent reviews shared by hotel guests
Elena M.
I’ve been coming to Sunset Beach for years, and every summer the service seems to reach a new level. It’s a fun place to relax with friends, with a vibe that feels different from the Hamptons. That’s why I love going.

Olivia M.
The food was awful and the prices felt unjustified, with no value for the money. The mussels tasted like onion soup, and the eggplant was sour and seemed spoiled. We asked for sunset seating but ended up tucked beside a bush with no view, and the service felt rushed. This seems more like a place to be seen than somewhere to eat. Save your money and go somewhere with better food and a better atmosphere.
Carlos M.
We had a great experience and can’t wait to return. The restaurant was on point and the food was amazing. Our room had a great view, and there was a bottle of wine waiting for us. My wife and I came to Sunset Beach for our 30th wedding anniversary, and we weren’t disappointed. The service was great.
Luis H.
We had fun on a late night out, though the kitchen closes at 7 p.m. We came back another day for food. The burger was a good portion, and the skinny fries went well with the chipotle aioli. The Espresso martini was enjoyable, but I didn’t think it was worth $25. Bees kept swarming the Frozé drinks, so I was constantly waving them away. They won’t hurt you, but it made for an uncomfortable meal, especially at those menu prices. In summer, choose your drinks carefully or you may have bees at your table.
Kaveh A.
The manager showed no respect for customers, and the restaurant staff were extremely rude and unprofessional. They openly shouted at a child who was just playing. Some customers left, and everyone was dissatisfied. The food was just okay.
Amenities
Everything available at this property
General Services
7 available- Shopping on site
- Smoke Free Property
- No elevators
- Reception desk
- Safe Deposit Box
- Concierge services
- Luggage storage
Internet
1 available- Free Wi Fi
Parking
2 available- Electric car charging
- Parking
Meals
3 available- Breakfast
- Restaurant
- Snack bar
Business Services
1 available- Event facilities
Pool and beach
2 available- Beach facilities
- Beach/pool towels
Children
1 available- Babysitting and childcare
Pets
1 available- Pets allowed
What's nearby
Explore attractions, restaurants and transport around the hotel
1.6 km 21 min walk
2.9 km 36 min walk
1.5 km 19 min walk
4 m 1 min walk
Attractions
20- Shelter Island Heights Private Beach Club1.5 km 19 min walk
- Fiske Field2.2 km 28 min walk
- Widow's Hole Preserve2.4 km 30 min walk
- East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation3.0 km 37 min walk
- Shelter Island History Museum3.1 km
Restaurants
20- Sunset Beach Hotel4 m 1 min walk
- 18 Bay Restaurant420 m 5 min walk
- Goat Hill Shelter Island718 m 9 min walk
- Vue718 m 9 min walk
- Endless Summer Grille718 m 9 min walk
Transit
20- North Ferry - Shelter IslandFerry1.6 km 21 min walk
- GreenportBus2.9 km 36 min walk
- GreenportTrain2.9 km 36 min walk
- North Ferry - GreenportFerry3.0 km 37 min walk
- North Ferry TerminalFerry3.0 km 37 min walk

Stay rules
Important conditions for your stay