The Crow's Nest

We waited an hour for a table by the water, where they have a little bar and tables with fire pits, and the wait was enjoyable. You can only get a reservation if you’re staying at the hotel. The views were beautiful, and the meal was phenomenal. The lobster pasta, beet salad, and scallops were all standouts. Drinks were good, but the food was the real highlight. The money, wait, and hype were all worth it.

The Crow’s Nest has a lively but intimate feel, whether you’re at dinner under string lights or having cocktails by the fire pits. The setting is beautiful, with sunset views over Lake Montauk. Its Mediterranean-inspired seasonal menu is fresh and well executed, from grilled seafood to colorful vegetable dishes featuring local ingredients. It brings together refined cooking and laid-back Montauk vibes. Definitely one of Montauk’s gems.

We saw Crow's Nest all over social media and decided to try it. The food and drinks were amazing, the best dinner of our trip, and the service was phenomenal too. We sat at the bar, where the bartenders were attentive and kind. Chelsea went above and beyond what any other bartender or server had done during our stay in Montauk. We’ll definitely be back.

Hagan made our night unforgettable, surprising us with champagne for the newlyweds and a special dessert for my birthday. We were celebrating my birthday and my niece Nicole’s wedding to Billy at The Crow’s Nest in Montauk, and every detail felt thoughtful and warm. The food was incredible, the ambiance magical, and the service exceptional. It was the best dinner in Montauk for a special occasion, and one we’ll always remember. Thank you so much!