Casa Aricò & Shatulle Suites

Casa Arico has a lot of character, and the welcome starts as soon as you arrive. Luca shares stories and helpful local tips that make you feel like family before you’ve even put your bags down. Mornings bring the smell of fresh coffee, Gabriella serving a generous breakfast, and gorgeous views from the rooftop or a cozy balcony. There’s quirky art and homely decoration throughout, including a sweet resident cat. The rooms are comfortable and distinctive, and being near the old city makes it easy to explore. We did notice a slight sewage smell from the bathroom, but Luca handled it cheerfully. He added some lovely incense and suggested covering the shower drain, which helped sort it out without a fuss. Whenever we had a question or needed something, Luca was quick and friendly about making it right. The house is central but peaceful, and the warm Sicilian hospitality makes it hard to say goodbye.

Taormina was such a good stay here. It’s tucked away from the busy streets but in a handy spot at the start of corso umberto and by the bus stations. Luca replied quickly and let me check in very early, which was a huge help since I’d already checked out of my other hotel. Ms Gabriella made a delicious breakfast spread and was the sweetest. I don’t know why this B&B is only rated 3 stars; it deserves at least 4. The cleanliness and attention to detail feel above that level. If you want somewhere with character, I’d try Casa Arico.

With just four rooms, this boutique place feels private and intimate. It’s beautifully furnished and in a superb location, with a very welcoming staff and no hint of snobbery despite the exclusive feel. Our room had a bathtub, and the water could get wonderfully hot, though you could adjust it to whatever temperature you wanted. The shared salon has a breathtaking view. Luca, the owner’s son, speaks fluent English and was easy to reach by phone or WhatsApp whenever we needed help. Gabriella, the housekeeper and cook, was warm and very accommodating.

We left after one night because this wasn’t what had been promised, and it wasn’t suitable for children. It felt like an adults’ house, with male nudes on nearly every wall, and the owners made us feel unwelcome. This is a shared family home, full of stuff, and our room was very small, with a queen bed rather than a king and nowhere to put our suitcases. The view from the room was of an old building, not the ocean. At $400 a night, it wasn’t worth it.